10 Best Toffees

Updated January 2026

Top Choice

1.

Global Gourmet Green Pea Soup, Jambalaya, Baked Lamb Shoulder, & Cantonese Banana Toffee

9.8

View Price

2.

Enstrom Milk Chocolate Almond Toffee 2.5lb

9.3

View Price

lowest price

3.

Fisher Butter Toffee Peanuts - 42 Oz. Cannister

9.2

View Price

Compare prices

4.

WALKERS NONSUCH Assorted Toffees and Chocolate Eclairs, 1.25Kg

Walker’s Nonsuch

8.9

View Price

5.

Gloria Jean's Butter Toffee Keurig Single-Serve K-Cup Pods, Medium Roast Coffee, 72 Count

8.6

View Price

6.

Milk Chocolate Covered Butter Toffee, 9 1/2 oz. (approx. 20 Pieces) from The

The Swiss Colony

8.3

View Price

7.

Primrose Assorted Toffees Wrapped 1.5 Pound

8.0

View Price

8.

Walkers English Creamy Toffees, 5.5 Pound Bag

7.7

View Price

9.

Toxic Toffee (An Amish Candy Shop Mystery)

WaterBrook Press

7.4

View Price

10.

Treacle Toffee World: Further Adventure

7.0

View Price